Skip to content

Lloyd’s Woodworking · Hudson, Massachusetts

By Lloyd’s Woodworking Inc. · Published

Why Does My Old New England House Have Woodwork I Can't Buy Today?

Share this article
Blue architectural entry door
A genuine Lloyd’s entry-door project illustrates how woodwork details can differ; it is not presented as a historic-property restoration.

DIRECT ANSWER:

Older New England homes can contain molding profiles, dimensions, wood species, construction methods and custom architectural details that differ from modern stock products. When only part of the original work is missing, custom millwork can sometimes reproduce compatible components instead of replacing everything.

YOU AREN'T IMAGINING IT.

THE NEW TRIM REALLY DOES LOOK DIFFERENT.

Older houses were built in different eras, with different materials, different manufacturing systems and different architectural expectations.

Trying to repair them exclusively with today's standard products can create awkward results.

BUILDING PRODUCTS HAVE CHANGED

Modern construction benefits enormously from standardized products.

Standardization makes building:

Faster

More predictable

More economical

But a house built generations ago was not necessarily assembled from today's standardized catalog.

That is why replacement can become difficult.

OLDER MOLDING PROFILES CAN BE DIFFERENT

Even when modern molding has the same general name, its:

Width

Depth

Curve

Projection

Proportion

may differ from the original.

Place the two pieces side by side and the mismatch becomes obvious.

OLD DOORS MAY NOT BE STANDARD SIZE

Older openings can vary.

Replacing a door may therefore involve more than buying a standard slab.

Consider:

Opening dimensions

Thickness

Hinge placement

Panel layout

Hardware

Casing

Threshold

Surrounding architecture

WOOD ITSELF CHANGES OVER TIME

Old wood can differ visually from new material because of:

Age

Light exposure

Oxidation

Finish

Use

Grain

Species variation

A perfect color match should not be promised simply because the same species is selected.

SOME ARCHITECTURAL DETAILS WERE ASSEMBLED FROM MULTIPLE PIECES

What appears to be one complicated molding may actually be several simpler profiles combined.

Understanding how the original assembly was created can help reproduce the overall appearance.

BUILT-INS WERE BUILT IN

It sounds obvious.

But it matters.

An original cabinet may accommodate:

An uneven wall

A sloped floor

An unusual corner

A chimney

A window

A specific ceiling height

Modern freestanding furniture may never fit the same way because the old piece was designed around the building.

OLD BUILDINGS AREN'T PERFECTLY SQUARE

And they don't need to be.

Custom work can account for field conditions rather than forcing standardized components into irregular spaces.

WHY NOT JUST REPLACE EVERYTHING SO IT MATCHES?

Sometimes that is appropriate.

But if 90 percent of the original woodwork remains, replacing all of it because 10 percent is missing can sacrifice a large amount of serviceable historic material.

Replication can sometimes solve the missing 10 percent instead.

CUSTOM MILLWORK FILLS THE GAP BETWEEN OLD AND NEW

Custom woodworking becomes particularly useful when:

Stock trim doesn't match.

A door opening is unusual.

A built-in must fit a specific room.

Historic material is missing.

A renovation requires new work to coexist with old work.

The objective isn't to make everything old.

It is to make new work belong.

SHOW US THE ORIGINAL.

============================================================

BEFORE YOU REMOVE IT, LET US SEE IT.

Original doors, trim, molding, built-ins and architectural woodwork may be difficult to replace once they are gone. Send Lloyd's photos before making an irreversible decision.

PREFER TO TALK? Call Lloyd's Woodworking 978-562-9007